The Rivalry Between J.R.R. Tolkien and C.S. Lewis
fot: pixabay

J.R.R. Tolkien and C.S. Lewis are two names that loom large in the world of literature. Their works, The Lord of the Rings and The Chronicles of Narnia, have shaped the fantasy genre and captivated millions. Behind these literary masterpieces lies a complex relationship. Their bond was marked by camaraderie, deep intellectual exchanges, and creative inspiration, but also by growing differences that led to tension.

The rivalry between these literary giants is a tale of shared passions and diverging paths, one that reveals much about the interplay of faith, creativity, and friendship.

The Formation of a Friendship

Tolkien and Lewis met in 1926 at the University of Oxford. Tolkien was a professor of Anglo-Saxon, while Lewis was an English literature scholar. They bonded over a mutual love of mythology, ancient languages, and storytelling. Both admired the epic tales of Norse and Greek mythology and sought to create worlds that could evoke the same sense of wonder.

Their friendship blossomed as they began spending time together, discussing literature, theology, and the craft of writing. Lewis, who had been an atheist for much of his early life, was profoundly influenced by Tolkien’s faith. Tolkien believed that myths carried profound truths and argued that Christianity was the “true myth” that fulfilled the deeper longings expressed in ancient stories. These conversations played a pivotal role in Lewis’s eventual conversion to Christianity in 1931.

Together, they formed a literary group called The Inklings. The group included other writers like Charles Williams and Owen Barfield. Members met regularly to share drafts of their works and offer feedback. This environment of collaboration and critique was instrumental in shaping their creative output.

Faith as the Foundation of Their Bond

Faith was a cornerstone of Tolkien and Lewis’s friendship. Tolkien’s Roman Catholic faith shaped his worldview and his approach to storytelling. He saw writing as an act of subcreation, reflecting God’s creation. His works are imbued with Christian themes, though they are rarely explicit.

Lewis’s journey to faith was more public and evangelical. After his conversion, his writing took on a clear theological purpose. His works, including Mere Christianity and The Chronicles of Narnia, were designed to communicate Christian truths in an accessible way. While Tolkien appreciated Lewis’s enthusiasm, he grew uneasy with the overt allegory in Lewis’s work.

Their shared faith initially strengthened their bond. They found common ground in their belief that storytelling could convey deep truths. However, their differing approaches to integrating faith into their work eventually became a source of tension.

The Creative Collaboration of The Inklings

The Inklings provided a fertile ground for creative collaboration. Tolkien shared drafts of The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, while Lewis read excerpts from The Chronicles of Narnia and his theological essays. Their discussions often sparked new ideas and encouraged them to refine their writing.

How The Inklings Shaped Their Work

  1. Constructive Criticism
    Members of The Inklings offered honest feedback, helping Tolkien and Lewis refine their narratives.
  2. Creative Inspiration
    The camaraderie of the group fueled their imaginations and motivated them to complete ambitious projects.
  3. Shared Themes
    Both explored themes of good versus evil, redemption, and the power of hope, though they approached these ideas differently.

While The Inklings fostered creativity, the group also highlighted the growing differences between Tolkien and Lewis. Tolkien found Lewis’s use of allegory overly simplistic. He criticized The Chronicles of Narnia for mixing mythologies and for what he saw as a lack of coherence. Lewis, in turn, grew frustrated with Tolkien’s slow pace and perfectionism, which often delayed progress on his manuscripts.

Diverging Paths: Faith and Fantasy

Though they shared similar goals, Tolkien and Lewis had fundamentally different philosophies about storytelling and faith.

Tolkien’s Subtlety

Tolkien’s approach to faith in storytelling was subtle and symbolic. He believed in creating self-contained worlds with their own rules and histories. Christian themes in The Lord of the Rings—such as sacrifice, redemption, and the battle against evil—are woven into the fabric of Middle-earth without being overtly tied to doctrine.

Lewis’s Directness

Lewis favored a more direct approach. The Chronicles of Narnia contains clear Christian allegories. Aslan, the lion, represents Christ, and his death and resurrection mirror the story of Jesus. Lewis’s intention was to introduce children to Christian ideas in an imaginative way.

Growing Tensions

Tolkien disliked allegory, calling it a “narrow and artificial” way of storytelling. He believed Lewis’s work lacked depth and was too didactic. Lewis, on the other hand, admired Tolkien’s intricacy but found his reluctance to finish projects exasperating. These creative differences began to strain their relationship.

The Impact of Their Rivalry

The rivalry between Tolkien and Lewis had both positive and negative effects on their work and friendship.

Creative Growth

Their debates and critiques pushed each other to grow as writers. Tolkien’s insistence on depth and consistency likely influenced Lewis to refine his world-building. Similarly, Lewis’s prolific output encouraged Tolkien to persevere in completing The Lord of the Rings.

Personal Strain

Despite their initial closeness, the differences in their creative and personal philosophies caused their friendship to cool. Tolkien felt Lewis’s popularity after the publication of The Chronicles of Narnia overshadowed his own work. Lewis, meanwhile, felt that Tolkien had grown distant and overly critical.

The Legacy of Tolkien and Lewis

Today, Tolkien and Lewis are celebrated as two of the greatest fantasy writers of all time. Their works have inspired countless readers, writers, and filmmakers. While their relationship was complex, it shaped their creative journeys in profound ways.

Lessons from Their Rivalry

  1. Collaboration Fuels Creativity
    The Inklings show how intellectual exchange and honest critique can elevate artistic work.
  2. Faith in Storytelling
    Both writers demonstrated how deeply held beliefs can inform and enrich storytelling.
  3. Respecting Differences
    Despite their disagreements, Tolkien and Lewis respected each other’s contributions to literature.

Why Their Story Still Matters

The story of Tolkien and Lewis is more than a tale of friendship and rivalry. It is a testament to the power of collaboration, the challenges of creative differences, and the enduring impact of faith and imagination. Their works continue to shape the fantasy genre, offering readers timeless lessons about courage, hope, and the human spirit. Through their shared journey, Tolkien and Lewis remind us that even the most complex relationships can produce extraordinary results.